Reflective account ethical dilemma treating cancer

Projections of the cost of cancer care in the United States: The first code of conduct for research including medical ethics was the Nuremberg Code.

How should a nurse handle a patient who will die without a blood transfusion, but refuses the transfusion based on religious belief?

Second, this responsibility leads to judgments and reasoning about the types of actions and behaviours which characterize a moral life [ 1 ].

Medical ethics

The list includes unnecessary use of chemotherapy for patients with advanced cancers who are unlikely to benefit, use of costly imaging technologies for staging of early breast and prostate cancers and for detection of breast cancer recurrence, and overuse of drugs to stimulate white blood cell production in patients receiving chemotherapy.

When a patient cannot participate, the family must be reminded to consider what the patient would want in this circumstance, not what the family or the doctor may want.

At the same time, the choice of these three specific cases highlights an increasingly common and important theme in oncology: We should avoid the pitfall of simply reviewing potential interventions. Advertisement We need to be very thoughtful about which drugs or technologies we provide and approve for use, meaning new agents and devices need to be a lot better than what is already available.

Medical ethics in an online world[ edit ] In increasing frequency, medical researchers are researching activities in online environments such as discussion boards and bulletin boards, and there is concern that the requirements of informed consent and privacy are not applied, although some guidelines do exist.

Ethical Diversity and the Role of Conscience in Clinical Medicine

Truth-telling[ edit ] Some cultures do not place a great emphasis on informing the patient of the diagnosis, especially when the diagnosis is serious.

Confidentiality is a fundamental part of professional tradition that protects human rights. Suicide The argument rages even today about whether or not people have the right to die when they choose to die.

Do not resuscitate: reflections on an ethical dilemma

For the most part, however, that discussion is not yet happening in the United States, where such a notion is equated with health-care rationing. It is also assumed by many FC opponents that conscientious conviction usually represents religious affiliation, and thus they assert that religious edicts and influences have no claim in the marketplace of secular healthcare [ 576980 ].

The remainder of this paper will focus on exploring issues related to FC freedom of conscience.

Facing Ethical Dilemmas in Oncology

Oncologists would be well advised to consider their obligations to the patient, as well as other stakeholders, and be prepared to resolve potential conflicts that go beyond the focus of their clinical training.

What should be done if there is no chance that a patient will survive but the family members insist on advanced care? This type of authoritarian approach to conscience rights has begun to be implemented in various jurisdictions and domains. These same advocacy organizations, however, often provide guidelines for care and disseminate pronouncements about how ethical practitioners should counsel individuals diagnosed with these specific diseases.

Brody, the ethical debate of rationing cancer care falls into two categories. Care and the attendant healthcare spending that does not serve these ends, or that is not discussed adequately with the patient, should be avoided.

Aboriginal elder; a layman; a laywoman; a lawyer and, in the case of a hospital-based ethics committee, a nurse. In essence, alleging intolerance is an effective way to preclude intelligent inquiry and to dismiss honest critique.

As the practice of medicine necessarily involves the incorporation of morals and ethics, varying interpretations of values should be expected and tolerated within Reflective account ethical dilemma treating cancer diverse group of professionals [ 87 ].

Failure to disclose the rationale for professional conscience decisions may leave patients confused, in a quandary, and perhaps feeling rejected for the evident disagreement.

Fundamental patient-centered values include honesty, faith that the caregiver will always act ethically and do what is best for the patient, and security that the clinician will never agree to covertly harming the patient.

Confidentiality Confidentiality is commonly applied to conversations between doctors and patients. Finally, as presented in the third case, discussions of prognosis and preferences are often addressed late in the course of illness, and a crisis may intervene before such discussions can take place.

With diverging views about what constitutes acceptable and professional behavior, one of the most formidable tasks facing the medical community is how to respond to ethical diversity within its membership. The example for this dilemma would be a patient that has no brain function, is on life support and has been for several years.

Finally, various contemporary ethical principles routinely provided to students in medical school training require some measure of ongoing scrutiny. This would be congruous in situations where political strife could lead such aid being used in favor of one group over another.

More recently, critics like Jacob Appel have argued for a more nuanced approach to the duty that acknowledges the need for flexibility in many cases. The role of oncologists in balancing these interests and meeting their primary obligation to the patient, while considering the limitations on this duty and their competing obligations to other parties, is well explored by Tenner and Helft.

Desire to avoid family conflict or discussions that may upset the patient, as the authors present in the second case, are both likely contributing factors. The perspectives vary considerably. Although the impact of stress of conscience among physicians is inadequately researched, there are some preliminary studies which document moral distress and the associated burden of anguish resulting from certain ethical situations among clinicians in nephrology [ 47 ], podiatry [ 48 ], general medicine [ 49 ], and critical care medicine [ 5051 ].

Amidst the plurality of values, ethical collision arises when the values of individual health professionals are dissonant with the expressed requests of patients, the common practice amongst colleagues, or the directives from regulatory and political authorities.

Telling the parents will allow Andrea to obtain treatment for her disease and as hard as it may be this is the right decision.A Common Theme Among Ethical Issues in Oncology: The Need to Individualize Advanced Cancer Care.

Jeffrey Peppercorn, MD, MPH; Feb 16, Incorporating New Developments in Diagnostics, Prognostication, and Treatment Into Clinical Practice—PART 2: ENKTL, EATL, Indolent T-Cell LDP of the GI Tract, ATLL, and. To ensure that appropriate ethical values are being applied within hospitals, effective hospital accreditation requires that ethical considerations are taken into account, for example with respect to physician integrity, conflict of interest, research ethics and organ transplantation ethics.

Ethical and epistemological questions relate to the methods that should be used to take existing evidence into account before the clinical trial is designed and ultimately approved. It has been argued that investigators have moral obligations to use the best current methods to assess existing knowledge before clinical research can be sanctioned.

Dec 12,  · In a climate of plurality about the concept of what is “good,” one of the most daunting challenges facing contemporary medicine is the provision of. Abstract. Nineteen speakers at the International Conference on Supportive Care--More than Medicine, which was cosponsored by WHO and held in Château Montebello, Quebec, Canada, Julypresented short introductory lectures and led the Ethics Working Group's discussions on the following ethical issues relating to cancer research and the treatment of cancer.

CHAPTER 11 Ethics and Health Pat Kurtz and Ronald L.

The Ethics of Rationing Cancer Care

Burr A terminally ill cancer patient who is in great pain begs the nurse for more medication than the physician has ordered. What should the nurse do? ing rights or obligations is known as an ethical dilemma.

Reflective account ethical dilemma treating cancer
Rated 5/5 based on 37 review